Is there evidence in Jared Diamond’s Guns, Germs, and Steel that supports his “due not to innate differences in the peoples” conclusion?

What is Jared Diamond’s conclusion?

Jared Diamond

The main conclusion of the book is that the success of one group of people in developing civilization earlier, and in eventually displacing others, is due to their good fortune of having locally available plants and animals that were suitable for domestication.

What is the conclusion of Guns, Germs, and Steel?

‘My main conclusion (of Guns, Germs, and Steel) was that societies developed differently on different continents because of differences in continental environments, not in human biology. ‘ Ah, so crisply well put.

What is the big question that Dr Jared Diamond tries to answer in Guns, Germs, and Steel?

JD: The journey of Guns, Germs and Steel started exactly forty years ago when I first came to New Guinea and was confronted face to face with the question – why these people had stone tools and yet I’d discovered that they were really bright people, why did such bright people end up with stone tools?

What is the main idea of this chapter of Jared Diamond’s Guns, Germs, and Steel?

Diamond’s main theme in Guns, Germs, and Steel is that the advantage of one society over another is not based on race or intelligence as some historians have claimed but instead on geography. Certain favorable aspects of local geography allow a group of people who live in that area to more easily produce food.

Is Jared Diamond’s theory correct?

Those were as accurate as possible when the book was written, and are not substantially different in 2020, even if some data has changed. However the main theory advertised by the book remains is based on environmental determinism, which is not an objective way to approach history.

What is the focus of Jared Diamond’s research what questions is he trying to answer?

Jared Diamond, the author of the book, has spent most of his career trying to understand why different human civilizations developed in different ways. The book will try to determine why certain societies became powerful and dominant on the global stage, while others did not.

What are Mcneill’s main critiques of Diamond’s argument in Guns, Germs, and Steel?

The book has raised much controversy, and many leading scholars disagree with Diamond’s approach. The main criticism against this book is that it neglects the impact of human agency and overemphasizes the role of geography.

What is Diamond’s argument?

At the risk of oversimplifying Diamond’s 440-page book, and the debate about it, the discussion goes something like this: Diamond’s book argues that the differences in progress for different societies around the world do not result from one group being smarter or more resourceful than another.

What was the impact of Guns, Germs, and Steel on the African continent?

The discovery of Mapungubwe overturned centuries of prejudice about African history and proved the continent played host to a sophisticated tropical civilization centuries before the arrival of Europeans.

What is the central question of guns, germs, and steel?

There, in 1974, a local named Yali asked Diamond a deceptively simple question: “Why is it that you white people developed so much cargo, but we black people had little cargo of our own?” Diamond realized that Yali’s question penetrated the heart of a great mystery of human history — the roots of global inequality.

What is Diamond’s answer to Yali’s question?

Diamond’s book-long answer to Yali’s question is, put simply–geography and food production.

What was Yali’s question and why did it set Diamond off on his quest for an answer?

Yali’s question posed a difficult challenge to Jared Diamond, sending him on a quest to answer why certain peoples have become more dominant in regions once occupied by others, why society has become broken up the way it now is, why certain groups became more powerful than others.

What specific historical event or case study does Diamond examine in his effort to answer Yali’s question?

This passage explicitly states the question that the book will try to solve. Another important thing to notice here is that Diamond illustrates the problem he’s attempting to solve with a “case study”: the colonization of the New World by European societies after 1492 A.D.

What is Jared Diamonds explanation for why the Spanish had advanced to steel swords while Incas were still making tools and weapons from bronze?

What is Jared Diamond’s explanation for why the Spanish had advanced to steel swords while Inca’s were still making tools and weapons from bronze? Answer: Because Europe was geographically close to the Fertile Crescent, they inherited the 7,000 years of metal technology that had been developed there.

How did germs play a role in the conquest of Latin America?

But then the Europeans arrived and a single Spanish slave arrived, infected with smallpox and the consequences were devastating. The disease emptied the continent, killing millions of indigenous people who lacked any prior exposure, and therefore any immunity.

What does Jared Diamond propose is the root cause for the disparity between cultures?

Jared Diamond’s basic theory is that some countries developed more rapidly than others and were able to expand and conquer much of the world because of geographic luck.

Why did Europeans have the technology to create effective swords but the Inca did not how was it related to their geographic contexts?

Why did Europeans have the technology to create effective swords, but the Inca did not? The Europeans had the technology to create effective swords because since the europeans were closed to the Fertile Crescent, they inherited this metal technology. What innovations helped the creation and spread of books in Eurasia?

What is Jared Diamond’s highly original theory?

These are questions that fascinate Professor Jared Diamond. He is on a quest to understand the roots of power, searching for clues in the most unlikely places. He’s developed a highly original theory that what separates the winners from the losers is the land itself – geography.

How did disease allow Europeans to conquer the native populations in the Americas and in the African cape?

3. How did disease allow the Europeans to conquer the native populations in the Americas and in the African cape? Answer: Europeans introduced germs that these populations had never before been exposed to, particularly smallpox.

How did the development of steel help civilizations gain power?

Steel helped civilization gain power by creating steel weapons and tools to farms.

How did guns help European exploration?

During the Age of Exploration, Europeans used guns and cannons to expand their trade networks and empires. Ships were equipped with cannons, allowing them to engage in naval battle and to attack ports. Vasco de Gama used this to his advantage and captured several ports in 1500 on his second voyage to India.

How the history of steel contributed to the conquest of the Americas?

The conquistadors who swept through the New World were armed with steel swords forged in the Spanish city of Toledo. Settler communities in North America and the Cape of Good Hope were able to capitalize on European-invented steel rails, steel locomotives and steel ships to transform their model European economies.